Above (top picture): Leader of the House and Deputy Leader of the Labour Party Harriet Harman appeared at the Dispatch Box to take Prime Minister’s Questions this afternoon. She was probably, for that half-hour, the most powerful woman in the country (executive power). Looking at her image, as it appeared on television (Daily Politics on BBC2) I saw a classic porphyrogenital icon that could have come straight from the pages of the Alexiad of Anna Comnena. Later I compared the image to a picture of the late Queen Mother - the last European woman “entitled” to wear imperial purple (in her role as Empress of India). The match seemed almost uncanny (although Harriet Harman had only one string of pearls to Her Majesty’s three). I showed this to Terry and he pointed out that Margaret Thatcher’s regal costume at a banquet in 1990 contributed to the general mood that “she had to go”.In the Board Room at lunchtime I watched Prime Minister’s Questions – the last of the year. Because the Prime Minister is in Iraq the Leader of the House, Harriet Harman, stood in for him. On the Opposition benches William Hague stood in for David Cameron.
The Leader of the House appeared power-dressed in purple. She exuded power. She praised the courage of the armed forces, currently involved in imperialist adventures overseas.
Labour’s Brian Donohoe asked why energy prices aren’t coming down now that oil prices have fallen.
The Leader of the House adopted a threatening tone, and said that not only would the regulators move against the energy companies but that the law would be changed if they didn’t act soon.
William Hague referred to the announcement that all British troops are to leave Iraq, and asked when a full enquiry would be held into the origins and conduct of the war.
Harriet Harman said there would be no inquiry while there were still British troops in Iraq.
William Hague said lessons needed to be learned from the Iraq experience, and then clumsily tagged on a question linking rising unemployment to the poor functioning of the banks.
Harriet Harman just as clumsily said again there would be no inquiry while there were still troops in Iraq, and then drew William Hague’s attention to the National Lending Panel (whatever that is).
William Hague rubbished the government’s efforts to stimulate bank lending and said the only answer was a national loan guarantee scheme (Conservative policy).
Harriet Harman said the Conservative scheme was “not worth the paper it is pressed released on” (this was obviously a prepared line, and she stumbled over its delivery).
William Hague responded by saying government efforts so far were “a reannouncement of a reannouncement” (again this line was obviously prepared earlier, and delivered faultlessly).
Harriet Harman said £1.3 billion was being channeled into JobCentres to help the unemployed.
William Hague accused the government of being “say anything, spin anything, achieve nothing.” He referred to the latest retail data, less than an hour old (gasps of “Ooo” around the chamber). He said the data proved the recent VAT cut had got a massive thumbs-down from the consumer.
Harriet Harman pointed to the Conservative front bench and said “All they do is carp and criticise”.
William Hague said he didn’t want any lectures.
Harriet Harman said she would rather have Superman than The Joker (a reference to Gordon Brown’s slip last week that he had saved the world).
Labour’s Judy Mallaber asked a meandering question about an exhibition just off the Central Lobby on the subject of votes for women.
Harriet Harman listed the women-friendly policies of the current government.
Liberal-Democrat Vince Cable, wringing his hands (which looked awful), told Harriet Harman that housing associations were in danger of collapse.
Harriet Harman told him she was very concerned.
Vince Cable told her she was being complacent. He said more bluntly that housing associations were going bust. He wanted to know what the government was going to do.
Harriet Harmon said the government had stabilised the position.
Labour’s Andrew Dismore said a disabled karaoke team had experienced discrimination at a pub in his constituency,
Harriet Harman told him “Discrimination against anyone is unacceptable in our modern society” (this said with such assurance that it is obviously one of her core beliefs).
Conservative Nigel Waterson said pensioners were suffering because of outmoded interest calculations.
Harriet Harman said, effectively, that pensioners had never had it so good.
Labour’s Laura Moffatt said the Conservative council in Crawley had abolished free swimming.
Harriet Harman said the Tories are bad people.
Plaid Cymru’s Elfyn Llwyd asked when the “hearts and minds” campaign would begin in Afghanistan.
Harriet Harman waffled incoherently.
Labour’s Brian Jenkins asked about the armed forces compensation scheme.
Harriet Harman told him it would be backdated.
Conservative Mark Pritchard referred to the abandoned enquiry into snatch landrovers and said the armed forces were not being protected.
Harriet Harman denied this.
Labour’s Julie Morgan asked when flexible working rights would be extended.
Harriet Harman told her the rights would be extended from April.
Conservative Richard Bacon asked about the future of the National Audit Office.
Harriet Harman told him “we will continue discussions”.
Labour’s Dr Nick Palmer raised concerns about possible open-cast mining in his constituency.
Harriet Harman said “we remain opposed to open-cast mining”.
Killer question of the session was delivered by a Conservative whose name I didn’t catch (he was dressed in a dark suit and wore glasses) who asked about Gordon Brown’s statement in 1996 “we will not build a new Jerusalem on a mountain of debt.”
Harriet Harman floundered at this point. She said (unconvincingly) debt had to rise now to avoid far worse debt in the future. As the Opposition jeered her authority seemed to fall away from her (briefly).
Labour’s David Crausby said water charges on churches were unfair.
Harriet Harman said lots of people had already raised this point.
Labour’s Adrian Bailey wanted to accelerate the Building Schools for the Future scheme as a way of generating construction jobs.
Harriet Harman said this was a good idea.
PMQs came to an end and the cameras went back to the studio where Andrew Neil looked disgusted at the performance.
PS sorry to have gone on so much about the appearance of Harriet Harmon. I don’t suppose anyone cares how she dresses. But it reminded me of the closing scene in Orwell’s Animal Farm where the poor old carthorse notices the “liberators” have become indistinguishable from the “oppressors”.
More on porphyrogenita: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porphyrogenita